This is a beloved story from last year. Enjoy.
The day was ending, a good chunk of free choice time and all of show-and-tell had been taken away because the students had been unable to control themselves inside and outside of class.
In light of these changes to the schedule, I brought out handwriting and history.
I know that I made history the most BORING subject of all time for those sad first graders, but I didn't quite realize to what extent I had done so.
Observe our conversation:
(I WISH I had had a recording device for this conversation!)After removing "Show-and-Tell" from their Friday schedule, I pulled out the history book and told them, "Now that you have finished your handwriting, we have 5 minutes before we need to pack up. I will use this time to finish our thoughts on the adventurer Robert La Salle."
Groans proceeded to ooze out of the poor students' beings.
"NOO!!"
Cries of,
"Boring!"
"No more!"
"This is a bad end of the day!"
followed the groans.
Simultaneously, two girls called out two of the funniest comments I have ever received,
"The day is ending like the roar of a lion!"
"The day has ended with the graveyard."
Followed by:
"This day started out well, but you have smashed my hopes into pieces!"
"Just let us do some PROJECTS in history!" (he said as his hands pulled the skin away from the eyeball in great desperation and despair.)
I silenced the crowd to hear the comments I wanted to hear.
One girl continued her thought, "I thought today was going to be a great day! I woke up and was so excited because today is crazy hat and hair day, we have computers, free choice, AND show-and-tell, but then we started talking at computers and now you took them all away. You smashed my hopes into little tiny pieces, like this."
At which point she held up her index finger and thumb pressed together in order to indicate the length to which I smashed her hopes to pieces.
The crowd cried out,
"That's right! This day has ended in the grave!"
"This day has ended like death!"
"I wish I had never been born!"
"I just want to die."
I asked, "All because of history?!" (Was I really making it that horrible for them?!)
To the declarations of
death, I did reply with a firm, "No, you do NOT say such things!"
One student then changed his response, "No, Miss Martin, I don't want to really die, I just want to be in heaven with the Lord rather than here." (Manipulation, right there.)
Once again, I silenced the crowd to hear the next comment.
Student, "The day has ended like a roaring lion."
Teacher, "What does that mean?"
Student, "It starts out so good and then it doesn't end very well."
To these comments I asked them whose responsibility it was to not talk, to do their work, to obey Mrs. Young, Mrs. Williams, Miss Martin, etc, etc. They acknowledged that this was their responsibility.
Suddenly, a charismatic and authoritative student raised his hand and stood up to speak,
"Come on guys, can't we choose to have good days? Can't we try to have a day like
this?"
To illustrate his point, he strode over to the HOW I ACT chart and began to take off all the letters people had been given that day. (It was SO humorous -- and yet foolish of me to let him continue. He really was in control at that point. ALL eyes were on him. ALL ears were listening to him. ALL bodies could be motivated by him. They could form a rebellious union. Despite my better judgment, I was intrigued and so let him continue his INSPIRATIONAL speech.)
"Can't we try for a day like this -(pointing to the HOW I ACT board)- where there are no letters?! Can we have our parents come to us with smiling faces" (and he smiled a Chesire Cat smile) "instead of coming to us like this?" (and he frowned).
"Couldn't we let them
sleep with smiling faces?" (and he closed his eyes with his smile.)
"We need to try for one day when we won't see this board with letters on it!"
As the crowd began to catch the idea with an energetic agreement, his fervor increased.
"Yes, we need to have a day without letters and then we will have
Miss Martin put
HER name right there! And then WE will give
HER letters!!"
As cries of joy errupted from the crowd, I collected myself to interrupt the revolutionary's message.
"No," I began with great sobriety, "we need authority. I listen to Mr. Lugg and he has placed me as your authority. You cannot give me letters. You must obey me."
Wihout physically acknowledging my words, the student changed the direction of his motivational address.
"We need to have a goal for no letters in one day so we can take ALL these letters off and then," his intesity began to grow, "throw the HOW I ACT board...IN TO...the...
GARBAGE!"
My classroom could contain themselves no longer. This student had just expressed their unspoken hope. They began to clap and cheer.
"Yeah!"
"Yeah!"
I suddenly realized I could no longer allow my curiousity to be my controling desire. "Okay, sir, take your seat. We need rules. We will not get rid of the board. These are the rules in our classroom. If you were able to go a WHOLE day with NO letters, we could have a party in celebration of no letters, but we must keep the board."
"A recess day all day long?!"
"Play all day! Play all day!" the chant began.
Oops. The motivational speaker didn't QUITE inspire them to be silent.
I signaled for silence to squash the riotous mass.
I then reminded them that that is how they get all their letters -- too much noise; not enough self-control.
hahahahaha
As we started our "end of the day" routine, the students began to calm themselves, and the motivational speaker sat a little higher in his seat. He had succeeded.
And I --while chuckling to myself-- praised the Lord that it was the end of the day and concluded that it may be best to reign in one's curiosity.